Skip to main content

Welsh Secretary Alun Cairns rejects AMs' probe appearance again








UK ministers have been accused of avoiding scrutiny by refusing to give evidence to assembly inquiries.



Mr Cairns said he was accountable to the Westminster Parliament, while Welsh Government ministers were answerable to the assembly.


Chief Secretary to the Treasury Liz Truss gave a similar response when she was invited as part of an inquiry into capital funding - money the Welsh Government spends on building projects.


Chief Secretary to the Treasury Liz Truss gave a similar response when she was invited as part of an inquiry into capital funding - money the Welsh Government spends on building projects.


In letters to the committee, Mr Cairns and Ms Truss said it would be more appropriate for Welsh Government ministers to give evidence.


Mr Cairns added that this was the third invitation he had received in recent weeks.



In letters to the committee, Mr Cairns and Ms Truss said it would be more appropriate for Welsh Government ministers to give evidence.4


Mr Cairns added that this was the third invitation he had received in recent weeks.


In a report last month, the committee said it was "particularly frustrating" Mr Cairns offered to meet AMs individually to talk about devolving tax powers instead of going to a public committee meeting.


Chairman Llyr Gruffydd said the committee did not want to "score points", adding: "We genuinely want to scrutinise."


Ms Truss was "avoiding her duty and responsibility because at the end of the day she is responsible for the borrowing limits in Wales," he said.

About Mr Cairns, he said: "The whole thing is disappointing - but on another level it's a farce because he is avoiding being scrutinised."

A Wales Office spokesman said: "The secretary of state for Wales is scrutinised by Parliament and the Welsh Affairs Select Committee. It is for the National Assembly for Wales to scrutinise Welsh ministers."


Popular posts from this blog

Jeremy Hunt’s Financial Statement Offers Only Uncertainty for Welsh Families

  Commenting on Jeremy Hunt’s shock economic intervention Welsh Liberal Democrat Leader Jane Dodds MS said:   “Hunt’s statement points to the despicable damage that the Conservatives continue to wreck on households, businesses and individuals. All his statement today has done is cause wider uncertainty for households and the businesses sector.   “The Conservatives are trashing the economy with every day that passes and creating havoc for peoples’ mortgages. Now they are planning to inflict even more suffering by raising energy bills, hiking taxes and slashing crucial public services. These service cuts will see knock-on effects to the Welsh Government as budgets for key departments like education and health may be squeezed even tighter.   “What’s worst is they are still determined to protect oil and gas giants from a proper windfall tax and they are still cutting taxes for the big banks.     “Truss and Kwarteng are symptoms of a wider problem. This entire Conservative par

Significant Gaps Remain in Welsh Government Building Safety Announcement

  The Welsh Liberal Democrats have welcomed progress announced today in the Welsh Government’s building safety announcement but have warned significant gaps remain. Welsh Liberal Democrat Leader Jane Dodds MS and Cardiff Liberal Democrat Group Leader Cllr Rhys Taylor addressing building saftey campaigners.   The announcement given by Environment Minister Julie James MS confirmed that 9 property developers have now signed up to the Welsh Government’s “Developers Pact” agreeing in theory their responsibility to remediate buildings they constructed with safety defects.   The announcement follows a lengthy campaign by leaseholders in the five years since the Grenfell Tower Disaster.   However, three major developers are still yet to reply.   The Welsh Liberal Democrats have stated that due to the Welsh Government’s failure to work with the UK Government on the Building Safety Act, they are left with little to no options to deal with the property developers who have refuse

Welsh Lamb Exports to the US Welcome - But the Conservatives Are Paving Over Other Cracks

  Welsh Liberal Democrat Leader Jane Dodds MS. "While we will of course always welcome more export opportunities for our fantastic Welsh produce, Liz Truss and the Conservatives are trying to plaster over the cracks regarding the damage they have already done to the Welsh farming sector.   "That is that they sold out Welsh farmers for cheap trade deals with Australia and New Zealand for nothing in return. This was spearheaded by Liz Truss despite Australian commentators even being in disbelief about how lopsided the deals were.   “Tariff free access by New Zealand in particular poses a direct threat to the survival of the Welsh lamb industry and the communities it supports, including Welsh language communities.   "If Liz Truss was supportive of such poor trade deals already, it does beg the question how much more damage she could do to the sector as the UK seeks revised trading arrangements with the likes of the US, Argentina and Brazil.   “This is of cou